The Supreme Court also ruled 6–3 on Friday that a Texas law requiring age verification to access porn sites is constitutional and does not infringe on adults’ First Amendment rights.
The ruling, in Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, could impact similar laws in at least 20 states, and comes as lawmakers work to regulate content children consume online. It could also trigger a wave of online speech restrictions as states grapple with protecting minors for harm.
INSIDE THE CASE
For the majority, conservative Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the law intends to protect children and does not directly impede access to protected material for adults.
The Majority Opinion: "The statute advances the State’s important interest in shielding children from sexually explicit content. And, it is appropriately tailored because it permits users to verify their ages through the established methods of providing government-issued identification and sharing transactional data," Justice Thomas wrote.
The Dissenting Opinion: Justice Elena Kagan argued the law creates a “chilling effect” on free speech and violates privacy rights by requiring adults to give up sensitive information – like government-issued IDs or facial scans to prove they are 18 or older – to access explicit sites.
The dissenting Justices reinforced that they do not believe children should have access to porn sites, but worried the law creates an unconstitutional burden for adults.
"Many reasonable people, after all, view the speech at issue here as ugly and harmful for any audience. But the First Amendment protects those sexually explicit materials, for every adult. So a State cannot target that expression, as Texas has here, any more than is necessary to prevent it from reaching children," Justice Kagan wrote.
Catch Up On The Latest Headlines
President Trump warned Monday that all of Iran’s bridges and power plants could be destroyed by midnight ET Tuesday — just four hours after his 8 p.m. ET deadline — if Iran and the U.S. do not reach a deal.
A search-and-rescue operation is underway for the remaining crew members from a U.S. fighter jet shot down over Iran on Friday. American forces rescued one crew member from the F-15E fighter jet, who is now safe and receiving medical care.
Ahead of Easter this Sunday, Catholic dioceses across the U.S. are reporting some of their largest groups of new converts in years.
President Trump announced Thursday that Attorney General Pam Bondi is out, becoming the second cabinet secretary fired in just four weeks.
We are just a couple hours away from what could be a major milestone for the Artemis II mission. The translunar injection burn, or TLI, will be final major engine firing that would set Artemis II on its way to circumnavigate the moon
Supreme Court justices heard arguments Wednesday over the constitutionality of President Trump’s executive order aimed at ending automatic, birthright citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants, temporary residents and people traveling here on visas. A majority of justices — including key conservative swing votes — appeared skeptical of the administration’s arguments about the order, which is currently blocked by lower courts.
Average gas prices in the U.S. rose Tuesday to over $4 a gallon for the first time since 2022. It comes just over a month into Iran war, and is the largest monthly jump AAA has ever seen.
An initial ATF analysis of fragments of a bullet that killed Charlie Kirk could not conclusively connect it to the rifle found on the scene that was tied to alleged assassin Tyler Robinson.
President Trump on Monday claimed “great progress” in talks with Iran, but warned he could strike the country’s power plants, oil infrastructure, and desalination facilities if a deal to end the war and for Iran to reopen the Strait of Hormuz is not reached.
There is no solution in sight. House Republicans rejected the Senate bill to fund most of the Department of Homeland Security, which it passed by unanimous voice vote early Friday morning.
Vice President JD Vance launched the White House anti-fraud task force Friday, arguing the federal government has failed for decades to take fraud seriously.